UCSF University of California, San Francisco      About UCSF       Search UCSF       UCSF Medical Center     
  Education & Training    Research    Patient Care   
 
 
Feature Archive
 

Resources for Investigators
Looking for assistance with industry partnerships? You can get the information you need from both School of Medicine and campus resources
more


Conflict of Interest
Investigators who work with industry should be aware of the conflict of interest policies in effect at UCSF
more


UC Discovery
The UC Discovery Fellows Program seeks to accelerate the delivery of tangible benefits from publicly funded research
more


Bringing Ideas to Life:
Breast Cancer Pharmacogenic Testing
05.07.07

(continued from previous page)


Clinical testing in the area of pharmacogenomics has great potential to impact patient care. But although markers of both drug metabolism and toxicity have been identified, testing for these markers has not yet been widely adopted by clinicians.

Recently an FDA advisory committee recommended that patients receiving the breast cancer drug tamoxifen be tested for variations in the gene (Cytochrome P450 2D6) primarily responsible for metabolizing tamoxifen into its active form, endoxifen.

Although there is clear data indicating that patients who are poor metabolizers of tamoxifen are at increased risk of breast cancer recurrence, the impact of this information on patient care is still unclear.

The only test cleared by the FDA for comprehensive analysis of variations in the CYP2D6 gene is the Roche Diagnostics AmpliChip CYP450 Test.

Tim Hamill, MD, director of the UCSF Clinical Laboratories, had worked with industry before, mostly as a test site for new equipment and applications. But last October, when the FDA panel made its recommendation to test the CYP2D6 gene in patients on Tamoxifen, Dr. Hamill and Laura Esserman, MD, the director of the Carol Franc Buck Breast Care Center, wanted to offer this test to breast cancer patients to clarify its clinical use.

"With any of these new tests, there is uncertainty in the beginning about the strength of the data suggesting a change in practice," notes Dr. Esserman. "We will continue to learn from this program, and others around the country, as they are developed."

Importantly, there are therapeutic alternatives, such as aromatase inhibitors, available if the tests indicate that tamoxifen will not lead to a favorable outcome.

Industry partner Roche Diagnostics developed the AmpliChip CYP450 Test using Affymetrix microarray technology, which enables the test to offer more comprehensive analysis of CYP2D6 variations.

"We wanted to increase pharmacogenomic testing capability at UCSF using this test as a pilot study, and approached Affymetrix and Roche," Hamill says. "We knew there was value for both partners: We would gain access and know-how to their technology, and we would have the opportunity to study and provide them with information about the psychosocial and clinical decision-making process that occurs around taking that test."

Often, technology is not the limiting factor in the use of pharmacogenomic tests, rather it is the complexities of introducing new information and practices into clinical care.


Once the initial conversation occurred, Drs. Esserman and Hamill called for expert help from the UCSF School of Medicine's Director of Research Technologies and Alliances, Teri Melese. "There are complex rules involved in these alliances," Esserman says, "and it can be difficult to navigate through all this. We got Teri involved in the beginning, so she could give us good advice."

"It was very exciting when Roche and Affymetrix signed on, because the UCSF Clinical Laboratories here at UCSF tends to be more cautious about the financial risk of ventures like this," Hamill says. "But we wanted the opportunity to start looking into pharmaco-genomics, because we're right on the cusp of adopting that technology now." This was a chance to build clinical array diagnostic capability at UCSF.

The team assembled to bring this project forward reflects the growing trend towards interdisciplinary efforts at UCSF. It includes investigators from the departments of medicine (Elad Ziv, Hope Rugo), surgery (Laura Esserman), laboratory medicine (Tim Hamill, Alan Wu), and from the school of pharmacy (Shareen El-ibiary).


Hamill notes that although the clinical laboratory had worked with many vendors, some academics have traditionally been reluctant to get involved with industry for fear it would taint projects with the perception of an ulterior motive.

"But a lot of industry leaders actually came from academia or from the clinical arena," Hamill says. "They understand what academia is all about, and that it is possible to work together toward a common goal."

Next Page: A Study in Asthma


Source: Susan Davis

back to top

Updated: May 17, 2007
    Site Map    Contact Info     ©UC Regents